Garland's Digest

on employment discrimination law

Chapter 22 - Attorney's Fees and Costs

Overview

22.100 Attorney's fees - general principles
22.200 Attorney's fees on behalf of employee
22.300 Attorney's fees and other sanctions on behalf of employer
22.400 Costs
 

Detail

22.100 Attorney's fees - general principles

             22.110 Burden of proof

                         22.111 District court's obligation to make explicit findings

                         22.112 District court's obligation to rely on evidence in the
                                      record

                         22.113 Prevailing party must prove entitlement to all fees
                                      claimed

             22.120 Standard of review

             22.130 Statutory authority for fees and costs

                         22.131 28 U.S.C. § 1927

                         22.132 42 U.S.C. § 1988(b)

            22.140 Statutory authority, by anti-discrimination law, for fee
                         awards

                          22.141 ADEA

                                       22.141.10 Whether Title VII's "prevailing party"
                                                           analysis applies

                                       22.141.20 Federal employee

                                       22.141.30 Standard of awarding fees to employer

                          22.142 ADA

                          22.143 Equal Pay Act

                          22.144 42 U.S.C. § 1981

                          22.145 42 U.S.C. § 1983

                          22.146 FMLA

                          22.147 Rehabilitation Act

                          22.148 Title VII

                          22.149 [Reserved]

             22.150 Purpose of awarding attorney's fees

             22.160 Miscellaneous

                          22.161 Standards for awarding fees under 42 U.S.C. § 1981
                                       and Title VII are identical

                          22.162 Standards for awarding fees under the ADA and Title
                                       VII are identical

                          22.163 42 U.S.C. § 1988 standard applies to fee analysis
                                       based on other statutes

                          22.164 Attorney's fees can be awarded under Title VII for a
                                       party prevailing in a state administrative proceeding

                         22.165 Standard for apportioning fees against multiple
                                      defendants

[Return to top of page]

 

22.200 Attorney's fees on behalf of employee

             22.210 General principles

                          22.211 Lodestar method preferred

                          22.212 Factors considered in lodestar

                          22.213 Prevailing plaintiff ordinarily entitled to attorney's
                                        fees            

             22.220 Prevailing party / catalyst theory

                          22.221 Nominal relief or no relief

                          22.222 What if mixed-motive defense is established?

                                       22.222.10 Mixed-motive Title VII retaliation claims

                          22.223 Relief on pendent state claims only

                          22.224 Injunctive relief that does not benefit the plaintiff

             22.230 Calculation of amount

                          22.231 Hourly rate

                                       22.231.10 District court has broad discretion

                                       22.231.20 Rates in local community

                                                          22.231.21 Prevailing rate for similar work

                                                          22.231.22 Attorney's normal hourly rate

                                       22.231.30 Whether to award current or historical
                                                          rates                      

                                        22.231.40 Examples of recent hourly rates awarded

                          22.232 Number of hours

                                        22.232.10 Multiple lawyers performing same task

                                        22.232.20 Duty to exercise "billing judgment"

                                        22.232.30 Specific issues

                                                           22.232.31 Hours for "jury watch"

                           22.233 Degree of success or "results obtained"

                                        22.233.10 Whether claims are related or severable?

                                        22.233.20 Victory on few claims and award of limited
                                                           relief

                                        22.233.30 Victory on most claims and award of
                                                           substantial relief

                                        22.233.40 Victory on most claims, but no award of
                                                           significant relief

                                       22.233.50 Victory on most claims and award of
                                                          limited, but not insubstantial, relief

                                       22.233.60 Comparison between ad damnum and
                                                          amount actually awarded

                           22.234 Time records

                                        22.234.10 Time records should be contemporaneous

                                        22.234.20 Time records should be meticulous

                           22.235 Pre-judgment interest

                           22.236 [Reserved]

                           22.237 [Reserved]

                           22.238 Multiplier for exceptional success

                           22.239 Other factors in determination of court-awarded fees

                                        22.239.10 Effect of offer of judgment or settlement
                                                           offer on award of attorney's fees

                                                            22.239.11 Calculating amount of judgment
                                                                               with respect to a Rule 68 offer
                                                                               of judgment

                                        22.239.20 Contingency fee

                                        22.239.30 Proportionality of fees to the plaintiff's
                                                            award

             22.240 Entitlement to fees for time spent litigating fee award

             22.250 Interplay between court-awarded fees and contingent fees

             22.260 Appellate issues

                          22.261 Effect on fee award when judgment for plaintiff is
                                        reversed

[Return to top of page]

 

22.300 Attorney's fees and other sanctions on behalf of employer

             22.310 Legal standard for awarding fees to employer

                          22.311 Reliance on attorney's advice is not a complete
                                        defense

                          22.312 Showing of bad faith not required, and proof of good
                                        faith is not a defense

                          22.313 Right to notice before sanctions are imposed

                          22.314 Dismissal for failure to state a claim does not
                                       automatically mean lawsuit was frivolous

                          22.315 Effect of offer of judgment or settlement offer upon
                                       employer's entitlement to attorney's fees

                          22.316 When is an appeal frivolous?

             22.320 Even if legal standard is met, decision to award fees is
                          discretionary

             22.330 Apportioning fees between frivolous and non-frivolous
                          claims

             22.340 Miscellaneous issues

                          22.341 Attorney's fees not recoverable as part of a Rule 68
                                       offer of judgment

                          22.342 When does a settlement qualify as a nuisance-value
                                       settlement?

[Return to top of page]

 

22.400 Costs

             22.410 Entitlement to costs

                          22.411 Burden of proof

                                       22.411.10 Employer can recover costs even though
                                                           lawsuit was not frivolous

                          22.412 Standard of review

                          22.413 Legal authority for awarding costs

                                       22.413.10 28 U.S.C. § 1920

                                       22.413.20 Fed. R. Civ. P. 54(d)

                                       22.413.30 42 U.S.C. § 1988

                                       22.413.40 Title VII

                          22.414 Interplay between legal authority for awarding costs

                          22.415 Prevailing party for purposes of costs

                          22.416 Court must provide a valid reason for not awarding
                                        costs to a prevailing party

                                       22.416.10 Reasons to deny costs to prevailing party

             22.420 Case law interpreting legal authority for awarding costs

                          22.421 Overview

                          22.422 28 U.S.C. § 1920

                          22.423 Fed. R. Civ. P. 54(d)

                                        22.423.10 Prevailing party

                                                          22.423.11 Nominal damages is sufficient for
                                                                              prevailing party status

                                              22.423.12 Both sides cannot be prevailing
                                                                             party                              

                          22.424 Title VII

             22.430 Whether particular costs are recoverable

                          22.430.01 Copying costs

                          22.430.02 Depositions

                          22.430.03 Exhibit costs

                          22.430.04 Expert witness fees

                          22.430.05 Investigative fees

                          22.430.06 Legal research

                          22.430.07 Mediation expenses

                          22.430.08 Service of process fees

                          22.430.09 Travel

                          22.430.10 Videographer

[Return to top of page]